The Round Table (Rational Pagans Forum)

Science & The Supernatural: A Discussion of the World Around us - Based on Science with an Interest in the Supernatural ...
It is currently 21 Sep 2018, 07:39

All times are UTC - 5 hours




Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 6 posts ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: 12 Apr 2010, 22:19 
Offline
Grand Poobah
User avatar

Joined: 18 Sep 2007, 11:26
Posts: 5793
Location: Buffalo, NY
http://www.csicop.org/si/show/review_of ... ame_to_be/

Quote:
Review of “Evolution: How We and All Living Things Came to Be” by Daniel Loxton

Two very different books about evolution crossed my desk recently. The first, by Richard Dawkins, is titled The Greatest Show on Earth: The Evidence for Evolution (Free Press). The second, by Daniel Loxton, is Evolution: How We and All Living Things Came to Be (Kids Can Press).

The fact that either of these authors felt the need to write their respective books is, in a way, somewhat bizarre and sad. Charles Darwin published his book On the Origin of Species in 1859; the world has had 150 years to digest and understand evolution, and evidence for Darwin’s theory has grown more robust with each passing year. In an ideal world, Dawkins and Loxton would be chided for wasting their time and effort pointing out the patently self-evident. What’s next, a book explaining to the public that the sun shines upon them every day?

And yet polls and surveys show that a significant number of people (around 40 percent, but depending on the exact poll question) have doubts about evolution. Some of them are creationists, but many others simply have never had evolution explained to them correctly.

Evolution by natural selection is not necessarily clear or intuitive. Evolution is not inherently obvious; it is a slow, complex process with many nuances. Whether stunted by a poor educational system or religious fundamentalists, it is a minor tragedy that one of the greatest scientific ideas in history remains the subject of dispute.

That is why books like The Greatest Show on Earth and Evolution are important. The former is meant for educated adults who want complete, well-rounded information on the evidence for evolution; the latter is aimed at children and teens who want a solid understanding of evolution’s fundamentals. Each is very appropriate for its audience, and paired together both books make a complete evolution literacy package (along with On the Origin of Species, which remains very readable). To be honest, I’ve not had a chance to more than skim Dawkins’s 460-page tome, though I expect it’s excellent. Loxton’s book, with only fifty-five pages and enticing full-color art on every page, is more accessible, and I’ll focus on that.

Loxton has a lot of ground to cover, and he begins by noting that different fossils are found in different geological strata—a fact that suggested to early researchers that many now-extinct animals had once roamed the planet (and much longer ago than most people could imagine). Evolution goes on to touch on a wide variety of subjects related to evolution, from DNA to the alleged “living dinosaur” mokele-mbembe. Along the way, new concepts such as species and mutation are introduced, often in the form of posed questions. Charles Darwin’s experiments are briefly described, including his research into avian inbreeding and the variations in beaks in isolated populations of Galapagos island finches. The elements of evolution are explained in terms that are neither dumbed-down nor too complex for its target audience.

Loxton, editor of Junior Skeptic, also shows off his considerable illustration skills. The book is clearly written for children, and eye-catching graphics are of course a necessity. Every page has one or more enticing, full-color images illustrating everything from dinosaurs to the bird-dinosaur Archaeopteryx to cute, flirty little zebra-like things called Zooks. This helps reinforce the important concept that evolution is not a stale, dry theory dusted off from irrelevant history or science books but instead a real, active process occurring all around us at this very moment. It’s rare to find such an accessible, dynamic treatment of the subject of evolution.

Evolution also wisely anticipates and addresses some of the most common anti-evolution fallacies (such as that the eye is too complex to have evolved naturally). This feature alone makes the book better than other simplified descriptions of evolution because it inoculates readers against bogus creationist arguments they may hear but would be otherwise unable to answer.

While the content of the book is very good, a few elements could have used better organization. For example, there are about a dozen sections that begin with a question. This is a useful way to present information, but the questions appear next to illustrated oval portraits of people whose relevance to the book is unclear. The questions themselves are fine, but I found the associations with anonymous portraits confusing at first. It might have been more effective if the book had begun with two or three recurring characters who would be asking questions on behalf of the reader throughout the book, instead of introducing a different, apparently random face each time. The book also needed a references or further reading section. Though Richard Dawkins is quoted several times in the text, for example, none of his books or articles are mentioned or referenced. Overall, however, these minor issues don’t detract from the book’s presentation and message.

I hope that 150 years from now books on evolution, such as those by Dawkins and Loxton, will be considered obsolete, a redundant parroting of basic facts that every schoolchild knows.

Until then, the world is sorely in need of high-quality, accessible science and skeptical books for teens and children, and Loxton’s book is an excellent and long-overdue introduction to evolution.
Ben Radford

Benjamin Radford is a scientific paranormal investigator, Managing Editor for Skeptical Inquirer magazine, and author or co-author of three books and hundreds of articles on skepticism, critical thinking, and paranormal investigation. He also wrote and directed two short films, and takes on extra projects in an apparent effort to deplete any free time.

_________________
Chloride and Sodium: Two terribly dangerous substances that taste great together!


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 13 Apr 2010, 12:10 
Offline
'Lustrous Potentate
User avatar

Joined: 24 Mar 2010, 11:06
Posts: 411
Public ignorance about evolution isn't surprising when there are states that do not have evolution in their science standards for education, and high school biology classes often completely gloss over the topic for fear of controversy.


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 13 Apr 2010, 12:13 
Offline
'Lustrous Potentate
User avatar

Joined: 24 Mar 2010, 11:06
Posts: 411
http://www.stateline.org/live/ViewPage. ... ntId=72494

Study flunks state science standards

Wednesday, December 07, 2005
By Kavan Peterson, Stateline.org Staff Writer

Quote:
The report also criticized a "disturbing and dangerous" trend by states to water down the teaching of evolution in response to religious and political pressure. Kansas, for instance, had its grade dropped from a "C" to an "F minus" after the state board of education adopted science standards critical of evolution in November.

Fourteen states were given failing grades for their teaching of evolution: Alaska, Arkansas, Alabama, Idaho, Kansas, Mississippi, Florida, Maine, Mississippi, Montana, New Hampshire, Oklahoma, Rhode Island and Wisconsin.


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 18 Apr 2010, 18:24 
Offline
Grand Poobah
User avatar

Joined: 18 Sep 2007, 11:26
Posts: 5793
Location: Buffalo, NY
:disgust:

At least I'm not in one of them.

Why would anyone live there?

_________________
Chloride and Sodium: Two terribly dangerous substances that taste great together!


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 19 Apr 2010, 14:17 
Offline
'Lustrous Potentate
User avatar

Joined: 24 Mar 2010, 11:06
Posts: 411
Wisconsin's inclusion on the list surprises me, because there is not a large fundy community here (the largest religious group in the state are the Catholics), and we have a reputation of being progressive.

I guess that it is just the way the state science standards are phrased more than anything else. Because to the best of my knowledge evolution is being taught in high school biology classes.


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 30 Jan 2018, 00:46 
Offline
Acolyte

Joined: 07 Jun 2017, 21:02
Posts: 56
Although not finished Michael Kors handbags in 2017,Salomon Shoes it should not be burberry outlet so urgent to montblanc pen run until 2018.Cheap Jerseys But fashion is always a fast one, is not it,Coach Factory Outlet Online so after a serious coach outlet online review of 2017's timberland boots fashion memorabilia,North Face Outlet Fashion King must non-stop disseminate Coach Outlet new trends for you.kate spade handbags Maybe you are still nike outlet wearing a thick Coach Outlet Store Online down jacket,nike air max 90 and even Coach Outlet Store Online two pairs of socks.Michael Kors Outlet But with Tory Burch sale the constant coach outlet online alternation adidas yeezy boost 350 day and night,coach black friday there are not oakley sunglasses cheap many days in winter,ugg boots Sale and you can swarovski Outlet see the vibrant Coach Factory Outlet spring right away,pandora charms sale which means your wardrobe needs adidas nmd womens to be renewed.valentino shoes Before that,Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses all you need to do under armour is understand the red bottoms for men latest trends of Nike Store the coming year,true religion then take the wallet.Skechers Outlet Wallpaper-style Coach Outlet floral pattern Timberland Boots Outlet If this year is Coach brand year,Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet this argument Ugg Australia is not an cheap Jordan shoes exaggeration.Cheap Ray-Ban Sunglasses In addition to being a oakley outlet popular element moncler jacket of Coach's Kate Spade fire this year,the north face next year a Ugg Outlet large area of flower cheap jerseys motifs burned by Coach Coach Outlet Online will also be wiped out.Coach Outlet Store Online In the spring ugg outlet of flowers,Ugg boots Outlet how can you wear a Ugg Boots little flower to longchamp outlet suit the scene,Tory Burch Shoes The modern chaussures louboutin pas cher khaki Although Coach Handbags Outlet the prediction canada goose clothing of this color ralph lauren outlet is not disruptive,ugg boots but in 2018 we can expect it to north face jackets be displayed in Michael Kors Factory Outlet different forms,New Balance Shoes such as Pleated skirt or Coach Outlet lotus nba jerseys wholesale sleeve shirt.Adidas Shoes Bold stripes here coach outlet is bold in two ways,nike free pas cher the color of the adidas yeezy boost breakthrough Michael Kors Outlet Online and the breakthrough lines.Burberry Outlet Store Compared to Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet the previous oakley sunglasses popular pinstripe,Cheap Jordan Shoes 2018 stripes will Moncler Outlet appear Asics Running Shoes more and more true religion jeans Outlet wide trend,Kate Spade Outlet but also in coach outlet color will be Salomon Running Shoes more and more daring.Coach Outlet Store Online Look forward to nfl jerseys this breakthrough the north face outlet innovation swarovski for our wardrobe.Ray-Ban Sunglasses Outlet Although this Ray-Ban Sunglasses cartoon T-shirt is timberland very difficult to under armour sneakers relate to North Face Outlet Online a mature woman,fitflops because it Swarovski Crystal looks so naive and the north face careless,Cheap Jordans For Sale but when you put moncler outlet store it into the high waist skirt,nhl jerseys wholesale and then Jordan shoes with a necklace,Stuart Weitzman it looks It will be a ugg boots very delicate shape.Salvatore Ferragamo Outlet Whether the Michael Kors Outlet heart-shaped pattern Oakley Sunglasses Outlet on your cuff,moncler jackets or chest or back,Michael Kors Outlet in short,Asics Running Shoes you should Prada Sunglasses let your heart Christian Louboutin Shoes feel the spring of ugg boots its expectations,Oakley Outlet Store if you feel too Polo Outlet high-profile,oakley canada you can choose a canada goose outlet smaller Christian Louboutin Shoes pattern.mont blanc pens Although the pink in Nike Shoes 2017 popular for Jordan Shoes a long time pink,Longchamp but in the nike shoes new year we Ray Ban Outlet Online look forward to Tory Burch Outlet a brighter color,Uggs Outlet to start moncler outlet the new year,Michael Kors Outlet on a pink basis,Ray Ban Sunglasses Outlet the appearance Fitflop Sandals of purple just to Michael Kors Bags meet Our expectations.skechers shoes outlet Although the pandora jewelry sale pink in 2017 coach handbags popular for a Coach Outlet Online long time pink,uggs outlet but in the cheap Jordans 11 new year michael kors canada we look forward to swarovski crystal a brighter color,Vans Outlet to start the new year,Oakley Outlet on a pink basis,Jordan Shoes the appearance of jordan shoes purple just to mont blanc pens meet Our sac longchamp expectations.Michael Kors outlet Pants-style Michael Kors Handbags Outlet dress Remember tory burch outlet this year,Coach Outlet Official popular skirts oakley glasses under the pants you do,Ray Ban Sunglasses this phenomenon vans store will intensify next year,Cheap ugg Boots in the elegant Oakley Sunglasses Outlet and sexy New Balance Shoes evening dress,Michael Kors Handbags with no longer Nike Air Max the legs but with ray-ban sunglasses canada neutral pants. Prada Handbags Outlet The black and Coach Outlet Store Online white is the most longchamp pas cher extreme of this popular.Coach factory Outlet Although ray ban sunglasses the girdle is Michael Kors Outlet Stores now more true religion and more Pandora Jewelry Outlet advocated liberation cheap ray ban sunglasses 00 of the breast,yeezy boost 350 but too open chest canada goose will make your cheap nba jerseys chest feel like an kate spade outlet empty room,Moncler Outlet and the emergence Uggs Outlet of girdle to Coach Outlet solve this problem,North Face Outlet the difference Christian Louboutin Outlet between the Ed Hardy Clothing previous Louboutin Shoes functionality more Coach Outlet Store decorative ornamental Sex.canada goose outlet store Exaggerated Pandora Jewelry earrings For some time coach outlet very popular minimalist oakley vault style jewelry,red bottom shoes but in 2018 Coach Factory Outlet exaggerated Michael Kors Outlet Online earrings will be the Polo Outlet new trend,ugg australia they will become your Christian Louboutin Outlet ear landscape.red bottom Coach bag bid farewell to polo ralph lauren outlet the winter Coach Outlet Online also means bid farewell to the big bag,Polo Outlet in the spring when to ralph lauren choose a Coach bag,Ugg Boots Sale let it Adidas NMD Womens reflect your exquisite Timberland Outlet Online and elegant bar. Cold wind,Kate Spade Handbags fashion icon autumn and winter fashion Fitflop Sale has been staged in the street.Coach Outlet Online Look at the style of Coach Outlet Store the autumn and winter Street beat,true religion it is not Converse Shoes Outlet difficult to Michael Kors Outlet find one of the Oakley Sunglasses Outlet protagonists Adidas Shoes Outlet of the winter nike air max 90 fashion is all michael kors online kinds of American boots,tommy hilfiger outlet whether it is handsome knee boots,Christian Louboutin Shoes or sexy Coach Factory Outlet ankle boots,adidas nmd R1 a pair of Christian Louboutin Sale boots with michael kors handbags a sense Cheap Nike Shoes of design to longchamp handbags outlet show the mix of cheap jerseys wholesale fashion people Heart machine!Canada Goose Outlet Whether your autumn and winter ugg boots shoes are few pairs Ray Ban Outlet of the most in Polo Outlet the United States boots,Coach Outlet Online Farfetch for Giuseppe Zanotti Design your selection of Coach Outlet Store highly popular fashion boots,Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses and offer a good discount,Adidas Shoes Dress up your winter look!


Top
 Profile  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 6 posts ] 

All times are UTC - 5 hours


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 10 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group