The Round Table (Rational Pagans Forum)

Science & The Supernatural: A Discussion of the World Around us - Based on Science with an Interest in the Supernatural ...
It is currently 19 Jun 2018, 14:44

All times are UTC - 5 hours


Forum rules


Please note: Discussion here should be relatively civil. Attack the post, not the poster. Thanks!



Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 5 posts ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: 11 Dec 2007, 00:10 
Offline
Grand High Lord Admiral of Hell
User avatar

Joined: 10 Sep 2007, 13:14
Posts: 5726
Location: Buffalo, NY
Perhaps it's just me, but after some of the discussants here (dramatic examples could be IIDB's Larsguy and afdave) have gone to great links to reconcile a literal belief of the Bible (especially the OT) with the factual evidence of archaeology/ historical documentation.

As an archaeologist, I'm of course of the opinion that artifacts trump documents, and a wealth of agreeing documentation trumps a single source. In this instance, I have issues with a literal view of the OT. The lack of geological/ genetic evidence of a 'great flood' and the lack of archaeological/ documentary evidence for the plagues of Egypt or the ensuing exodus cast enough doubt in my mind that I just logically couldn't see a literal interpretation of the OT, case closed.

Now, with that in mind, when I see something like Harpur's work getting such publicity, I can only think that Christians are looking for ways to discount a literal view in order to hang onto the structure/worldview of the NT and thus have a basis for the messages encoded within.

Why is it that so many people cannot simple push the OT into the 'myth/legend' category, but seem to need to have it all, word for word (in the KJV :tongue3: ) be true?

I just don't get it. :dontknow:


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 09 Oct 2008, 20:05 
Offline
Acolyte

Joined: 09 Oct 2008, 11:25
Posts: 24
Location: Deepest, Darkest NZ
Perhaps an article I wrote recently might help?

Quote:
Genesis 1 & 2: Fact or Parable?
by: Ray McIntyre

As a Christian living today there are a number of voices who claim to be speaking for all of us, they assail science and insist that we must literally accept every word in the Bible as true. In doing so they fail both themselves and others for much in the Bible is parable or metaphor. When we, as Christians, insist that parable must be accepted as literally true we put a stumbling block of, well, biblical proportions in the way of earnest seekers.

It is for such seekers that I write this article.

Should you happen to visit the Answers in Genesis site you will find, among other things the following comment,

"... We return to the question which forms the title of this article. Should Genesis be taken literally?

Answer: If we apply the normal principles of biblical exegesis (ignoring pressure to make the text conform to the evolutionary prejudices of our age), it is overwhelmingly obvious that Genesis was meant to be taken in a straightforward, obvious sense as an authentic, literal, historical record of what actually happened..."

But are they right?

Modern science shows that the earth is billions of years in age, it comes to this conclusion in a number of ways and I recommend the following site for information even a non-scientist can understand, http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/faq-age-of-earth.html .

Is there then a meeting place between science and the Book of Genesis? Yes, there is and it comes from the understanding that Genesis is not a science text-book, that it was written in order to understand, not HOW the world came to be but WHY.

Genesis 1 & 2 are parables, they are parables about why there is an earth, why humans and animals and plants share it in common and why there is pain and suffering in the world. Parables are stories which may or may not be literally true but which imparts to us an important spiritual truth. In the New Testament we have parables such as the Good Samaritan, the evil vine-dressers; the parable of the prodigal son.

None of those New Testament stories are literal fact but they are true in a deeper, more meaningful way. So it is with the parables of Genesis 1 & 2. In them we are not being told that the world was created in six days, six thousand years ago. We are, however, being told that the world was created by God's intention, that human beings are made in the image and likeness of God and that God is a close to us as a friend who walks and talks with us in the cool of the day.

Adam and Eve, the Fall, the Serpent, Noah and his Ark may or may not be literal truth but they are markers of ultimate truth, of truth which can be held only in the imagination, of truth which can only be shown in images and symbols.

Genesis can only be understood in that it is our story, each of us is Adam, each of us is Eve, we misunderstand the Genesis parables when we fail to realize that they are addressed to US individually. Genesis, then, is our unique, individual story told as parable it is not some pre-scientific attempt to explain how all things came to be but rather a profound series of meditations on why things should be in the first place.

Once we realize this, we can see there are no contradictions, can be no contradictions between the findings of science and God's word to us in Genesis. Let us happily give up our insistence on a literal Genesis and seek the deeper, religious truths that await us there.

Ray McIntyre is a Priest and Theologian living in New Zealand.

_________________
"If the cross is the sign of anything, it's the sign that God has gone out of the religion business and solved all of the world's problems without requiring a single human being to do a single religious thing." Robert Farrar Capon


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 11 Oct 2008, 21:10 
Offline
Grand High Lord Admiral of Hell
User avatar

Joined: 10 Sep 2007, 13:14
Posts: 5726
Location: Buffalo, NY
Well, the parable aspect works nicely to reconcile the two. I've heard plenty of explanations that work out to 'Well, seven days for God could be millions of years for us', which I can see people rationalizing.

I guess what I'm really looking to here is more of the literal, 'It's ALL the absolute truth of GOD' sort of stuff, where they blindly bend or warp facts and data, or go through convoluted arguments to make the same fit. :dontknow:

All parable, I can see fitting with science. :thumbright:

All literal, I just don't get ... :umm:

_________________
If you can't stand the heat, don't tickle the dragon ...


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 12 Oct 2008, 09:29 
Offline
Neighbor of the Beast

Joined: 03 Nov 2007, 09:17
Posts: 667
I think one of the difficulties with most of the individuals that require "literal truth" is that they lack in imagination. I do not say that this is so for all, but it is true for some. I know people that fall into this category that simply plod through life thinking and doing in all things, from their faith in the divine to brushing their teeth, simply because that is what they have been told to think and do.

Others find comfort it assigning order to the chaotic world that science embraces. They have so little meaning in their lives that they need someone to tell them that it is all for a purpose, it all has meaning. If they do not accept the bible as literal truth, they may be asked to admit that their belief simply requires them to have "faith". They would rather have assurances and guarantees.

I have always believed that true Faith will stand the test of time and the challenges of those that do not believe.

I do not possess such faith in any dogmatic religion, however, so I am using the outsider's view...


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 06 Jul 2017, 21:46 
Offline
First Circle Initiate

Joined: 27 Mar 2017, 03:16
Posts: 187
force soccer shoes of the swarovski online Red Army's nike air max security, at the swarovski expense nike mercurial of local interests oakley sunglasses outlet alone. givenchy handbags Take the leadership of longchamp outlet our armani shoes outlet long jimmy choo shoes march, the leading cadres pandora uk must michael kors outlet online strengthen the redskins nfl jersey politicawareness, oakley vault the long champ overall situation, packers nfl jersey the hollister core consciousness, cheap nhl jerseys sense brooklyn nets jersey of nike consciousness, consciously timberwolves jersey ideological cheap ray ban action on the party with polo ralph lauren the hogan outlet party levi's jeans to maintain panthers nfl jersey a free run high wizards jersey degree nike air max of mbt mens shoes consistency, horloges the majority occhiali oakley of coach factory outlet party kids hoodies members michael kors should consciously celine bags do nike free communism michael kors bags lofty Ideals ralph lauren black friday and the nike shoes common ideals omega watches of chiefs nfl jersey socialism with Chinese north face characteristics, reebok faithful practitioners, oakley black friday so puma sneakers that our party philadelphia 76ers jerseys is adidas outlet more cheap oakley sunglasses united converse sneakers and strong. giants nfl jersey Rooted lions nfl jersey people salvatore ferragamo fertile true religion outlet soil, giuseppe shoes blooming burberry handbags revival Fanghua. mont blanc On the new balance way nike to christian louboutin the oakley sunglasses long ferragamo shoes march, along burberry handbags the michael kors handbags masses for the nike outlet store Red cheap jerseys Army fund-raising, cooking water, collecting jordan intelligence, rescue the rolex replica wounded, asics gel to ray ban sonnenbrillen provide vikings nfl jersey military nfl jerseys sources. north face It ray ban can timberland shoes be oakley sunglasses outlet said that a pandora history michael kors of the nike free run Red lunette oakley Army polo ralph lauren outlet online Long March new balance canada is under armour curry a cheap jerseys vivid burberry sale history fake rolex that salomon reflects the ecology of the azcardinals nfl jersey military and five finger shoes the plein outlet people. grizzlies jersey In prada shoes fact, adidas with atlanta hawks jersey the new balance people all michael kors the titans nfl jersey way dolphins nfl jersey counterparts cheap glasses in the coach handbags 95 michael kors years mcm bags of magnificent saints nfl jersey history ralph lauren outlet of kings jersey the chargers nfl jersey Communist hollister kids Party ralph lauren online shop of China continue to hollister grow michael kors and michael kors outlet develop, and now juicy couture outlet has tommy hilfiger since cartier montres the establishment omega of barbour jackets dozens vans shoes of party members developed timberland boots into marc jacobs more http://www.nba-shoes.com/ than ray ban sunglasses 8800 michael kors taschen million bills nfl jersey members steelers nfl jersey of bcbg max the true religion jeans men world's most powerful max shoes ruling party. timberland outlet Winning ray ban the nike huaraches "thirteen ralph lauren outlet online five", prada should dre beats adhere new balance outlet to the hollisterco people as jaguars nfl jersey the center. Xi Jinping, longchamp outlet general secretary clearly rockets jersey pointed michael kors handbags out longchamp black friday that the coach outlet canada long march pandora charms is handbags outlet always north face on oakley the road. aktienkurse adidas The north face outlet spirit of dsquared2 outlet the wedding dresses Long barbour jackets March tommy hilfiger embodies the coach handbags outlet fine thomas sabo traditions and styles ray ban of air jordan shoes the converse Party and the beats by dr dre Red nike shoes outlet Army. ray bans It coach outlet online is a chaussure timberland comprehensive hollisterco display oakley vault of nike air force the Chinese eyeglasses stores people's michael kors purses world lacoste outlet online outlook, swarovski jewelry outlook nike air max 2014 on life and bucks jersey values, nike air huarache and a valuable spiritual juicy couture wealth of fidget spinner the nike outlet Chinese nation. burberry sale With cheap clothes this spirit, new balance shoes there air max is versace clothes nothing longchamp to coach outlet sale overcome designer handbags the difficulties, seahawks nfl jersey we fendi bags are chi hair fully confident that there coach outlet online is cheap mlb jerseys determination to texans nfl jersey persevere michael kors outlet in jordan jerseys the great rejuvenation of nba jersey the nike Chinese nation cheap true religion to achieve the Chinese dsquared2 jeans dream. discount shoes Cherish jerseys from china the memory of hilfiger online shop the nike roshe martyrs. babyliss pro Today burberry handbags outlet is the burberry "two oakley hundred cavaliers jerseys years" to air max one achieve nike air yeezy the coach factory online goal michael kors of nike tracksuits the new long adidas canada march, our raptors jersey generation must carry bears nfl jersey forward the spirit hilfiger outlet of michael kors handbags the Long March, ray ban sunglasses outlet take our generation true religion of hogan long ray ban outlet road, build a national beats by dr dre revival the north face dream.Carry forward ipad mini cases the composition vans of oakley sunglasses the Long oakley MarchFrom louboutin outlet 1930 nike roche run onwards, Chiang Kai-shek mobilized the army air max 90 on the mcm handbags central hermes birkin bag revolutionary louboutin outlet base for broncos nfl jersey four mcm handbags consecutive "encirclement oakley sunglasses cheap and suppression", phoenix suns but indoor soccer shoes failed the north face outlet in the ray ban end. In roshe runs the ray ban outlet autumn of ralph lauren 1933, north face backpacks the coach store online Red coach factory Army ralph lauren outlet online organized michael kors outlet online the basketball shoes fifth "anti-encirclement and suppression". pacers jersey As kate spade outlet online the trail blazers jersey CCP's interim center rams nfl jersey completely abandoned Mao colts nfl jersey Zedong's military polo ralph line, philipp plein clothing and prada outlet insisted hermes bags on kate spade outlet online carrying roshe run out Wang ray ban wayfarer Ming's fossil uhren "leftist" calvin klein underwear wrong claim, the watches canada fifth michael kors canada "anti-encirclement northface and nike roshe suppression" beats audio failed. In orlando magic jersey October air max 90 1934, tommy hilfiger more oakley sunglasses outlet than ferragamo shoes 80,000 ralph lauren uk people from the coach store outlet Central Committee of hermes the ralph lauren factory store Communist hogan women shoes Party hollister of China christian louboutin shoes (CPC) jimmy choo outlet and the Central Red Army were supra footwear forced nike to leave 49ers nfl jersey the tn pas cher Central nike free run 5.0 Revolutionary replica rolex Base and nike began ralph lauren polos the Long air force March. cheap oakley Zunyi ferragamo meeting, thomas sabo under ralph lauren polo the leadership of coach store Mao Zedong, huarache the oakley canada Red occhiali ray ban Army polo ralph lauren to converse overcome the cheap oakley sunglasses dilemma, ecco outlet online Chiang Kai-shek's rolex watches military jets nfl jersey besieged, burberry outlet but clippers jersey also ralph lauren outlet can handbags outlet not stop golden state warriors jerseys the coach purses factory Red new orleans pelicans Army's road ray-ban sunglasses course, on the contrary, they are nike air max 2014 more eagles nfl jersey and cheap barbour jackets more dallas mavericks jerseys courageous michael kors handbags ... swarovski canada ... 1936 kate spade bags October, the Red jordans Army marc jacobs victory nike Air Max Plaza arrived in nike outlet northern Shaanxi, kevin durant jersey The raiders nfl jersey victory buccaneers nfl jersey of the north face Long March oakley sunglasses victory over. coach bags The bottega veneta victory air jordans of michael kors outlet the Long converse shoes March cheap oakley sunglasses not mcm handbags outlet only red bottom shoes shattered coach factory outlet online the plot of the Kuomintang, cheap nhl jerseys but ed hardy also made longchamp the michael kors purses bureau to cheap jordans turn ray ban black friday the louboutin uk corner. Yeah! ralph lauren outlet online The valentino Long chrome hearts store March knockoff handbags can be swarovski crystal described giuseppe zanotti sneakers as nba jerseys a baseball bats loud veneta and straightforward jazz jersey hymn, it cheap mlb jerseys has inspired coach black friday the jordans number bengals nfl jersey of pandora people longchamp with michael kors outlet online lofty cheap jerseys ideals bcbg max azria to follow longchamp handbags ... ... ralph lauren the Long March burberry sale has given omega watches people chi flat iron how much polo ralph lauren outlet shock, cheap michael kors how much adidas feeling, it browns nfl jersey makes michael kors bags people not katespade help the ralph lauren revolutionary air max martyrs have charlotte hornets jerseys a barbour outlet online deep coach outlet memory vans And mizuno running reverence. louboutin Although puma online the cheap nike shoes long march san antonio spurs jersey is boston celtics gone, patriots nfl jersey but air jordan retro it air max is dwyane wade jersey not michael kors afraid of hollister co danger, perseverance iphone 5 cases of air max 2015 the dauntless spirit michael kors purses is woolrich mens jackets enough nba jersey to ralph lauren comfort the ethereal ethereal burberry handbags outlet heart. Although not immersive to air max go through prada handbags that true religion jeans women mighty revolutionary michael kors black friday years, ray ban outlet online but nike mercurial also instyler between lunette ray ban the pandora schmuck lines to tory burch shoes read burberry sale the replica rolex long hilfiger outlet march too falcons nfl jersey hard swarovski jewelry and adidas online difficult. mcm bags Yeah! barbour jackets A michael kors lot ray ban sunglasses outlet of nights, coach handbags I cheap true religion have more supra shoes than once to consider to ray bans chew the knicks jersey spirit adidas outlet of the celine black friday Long asics March north face jackets to tommy hilfiger give ralph lauren online me adidas the inspiration nike air huarache and nike.com vibration. burberry The cheap michael kors long march hugo boss clothes is kobe bryant jerseys forging nike air max ahead and roshe letting people never nike air max give ray ban outlet up. pandora jewelry It tells me softball bats that burberry there denver nuggets jersey is burberry outlet online no faith michael kors outlet online sale in burberry outlet store faith prada sunglasses and cowboys nfl jersey a ravens nfl jersey firm nike canada

red bottoms


Top
 Profile  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 5 posts ] 

All times are UTC - 5 hours


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
cron
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group