The Round Table (Rational Pagans Forum)

Science & The Supernatural: A Discussion of the World Around us - Based on Science with an Interest in the Supernatural ...
It is currently 17 Dec 2017, 20:08

All times are UTC - 5 hours


Forum rules


Please note: Discussion here should be relatively civil. Attack the post, not the poster. Thanks!



Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 5 posts ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: 11 Feb 2008, 14:20 
Offline
Grand High Lord Admiral of Hell
User avatar

Joined: 10 Sep 2007, 13:14
Posts: 5726
Location: Buffalo, NY
Does a cave prove Romulus and Remus are no myth?

By Andrea Pitzer, Special for USA TODAY

The discovery of an ancient Roman cave has unearthed a debate about its historical purpose and delved into a deeper question for scholars: Can archaeology prove mythology?

The cave was found when a camera was lowered through a hole in Rome's Palatine Hill during restorations of the palace of the Emperor Augustus, who ruled from the late first century B.C. until his death in A.D. 14. The Palatine Hill was a seat of power in ancient Rome; today it is home to the fragile remains of palaces and temples.

The discovery of the vaulted cavern, more than 50 feet underground and covered in mosaics, was announced in November. Some believe it is a shrine of the Lupercale, the sacred cave where Romulus and Remus, the legendary founders of Rome, are said to have been suckled by a wolf —lupa in Latin.

According to Roman mythology, the twin sons of a priestess and Mars, the god of war, were set adrift in the Tiber River. Instead of drowning, the infants washed ashore.

Francesco Rutelli, Italy's Minister of Culture, says the cave is the Lupercale celebrated in Augustus' time, as evidenced by references in 2,000-year-old texts.

Archaeologist Andrea Carandini of Rome's La Sapienza University calls the finding "one of the greatest discoveries ever made" and says the chances are "minimal" that the cave is not the site revered by the Romans as the Lupercale.

Carandini and others point to discoveries such as the cave and earlier findings of ancient structures as evidence that myths about the city's founding reflect history, and say that the founder of Rome may actually have been named Romulus.

Subject to interpretation

But linking artifacts to legends is risky business, say historians and other archaeologists.

"Everyone always wants to think that archaeology has proved the Bible is true, or that there really was a Trojan War, or that King Arthur was a real character," says historian T.P. Wiseman of England's University of Exeter. "Archaeology by its nature can't provide such evidence."

He says that when archaeologists interpret an artifact, their expert perspective is essentially a best guess, because there's no means of confirmation.

Historian Christopher Smith of Scotland's University of St. Andrews notes that even if artifacts clearly reference the Romulus and Remus story, all they will show is that the cavern is a place where first-century Romans celebrated the legend — not that the story is real.

"It is tempting to argue that the finds support historical events," Smith says, "when in fact they merely support ancient beliefs about events."

Wiseman says everything we believe we know about the ancient world must be treated as a hypothesis, one that may be disproved by future finds. The only concrete relationship between an artifact and a myth is "what people create with their own will to believe."

Earlier discoveries linked to Romulus and Remus, who supposedly founded Rome in 753 B.C., have divided experts.

In 1988, Carandini discovered a section of wall in Rome dating from the eighth century B.C., which he linked to a boundary found in the legend: Romulus killed Remus when he mocked such a wall. Other archaeologists and historians have recognized the validity of Carandini's find as an archaeological discovery but don't see it giving credence to mythology.

The Capitoline Wolf, a bronze statue of a wolf suckling a pair of infant boys, has come under fire. Long believed to be a fifth-century B.C. Etruscan statue, it may be much younger than that. Last year, Anna Maria Carruba, who was involved in its restoration, published a book claiming the process showed that the wolf was made outside Italy during the medieval period.

If so, Wiseman says, the statue is no longer proof that fifth-century B.C. inhabitants knew the story of Romulus and Remus, which had added weight to the argument that the legend might have historical roots.

Archaeologist Adriano La Regina, also of La Sapienza, who was in charge of the city's archaeological excavations from 1976 to 2005, is among those who argue that the newly discovered cave is not the Lupercale. Ancient sources, from the writings of Dionysius to Cicero, indicate otherwise, he says.

Historian Mario Torelli of Italy's University of Perugia suggests the chamber is only a grotto of the Palatine palace, included in the historical record since the 16th century.

...

Still, Mayor is impressed that the ancient story of the nurturing wolf has survived at least 2,000 years and has meaning for people today. Trying to connect with the past, "humans return again and again to archaeology to confirm the reality of myth," she says. "It's a timeless impulse."

_________________
If you can't stand the heat, don't tickle the dragon ...


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 11 Feb 2008, 16:17 
Offline
Grand High Lord Admiral of Hell
User avatar

Joined: 10 Sep 2007, 13:14
Posts: 5726
Location: Buffalo, NY
I actually hope to be able to comment/discuss on this topic. The question of whether archaeology can discern religious artifacts/locations is one that I started to bring up on IIDB's BC&H forum some time back, but shelved. I'd really like to explore it more ...

_________________
If you can't stand the heat, don't tickle the dragon ...


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 11 Feb 2008, 16:32 
Offline
First Circle Initiate
User avatar

Joined: 11 Dec 2007, 00:23
Posts: 173
Why am I not surprised that T. P. Wiseman is skeptical? Heheh. Anyway, even if it is the Lupercale, which I think it is, it in no way proves anything about whether or not Romulus and Remus actually existed. Remus especially is surely mythical, especially on account of his name (a PIE word related to Ymir and meaning "twin").


Top
 Profile  
 
PostPosted: 11 Feb 2008, 16:47 
Offline
First Circle Initiate
User avatar

Joined: 11 Dec 2007, 00:23
Posts: 173
These are my brief comments from my blog:

http://neonostalgia.com/weblog/?p=361

"Already on some obscure email list I noticed that one person praised the find as proof that Romulus had founded Rome. Seriously, a spade in one hand and…Livy in the other?"

Specifically, on Nova Roma, some of these Roman pagans thought that this was proof of Rome's founding. However, note earlier reports:

http://neonostalgia.com/weblog/?p=96

Specifically the article on how certainly the dates proposed are much much later than Rome's actual founding. I think even Ennius, who dates the founding of Rome the farthest back, only places it in the 9th century BCE, while the founding could be no later than the 10th.


Top
 Profile  
 
 Post subject: yueqin
PostPosted: 17 Aug 2017, 08:44 
Offline
Acolyte

Joined: 17 Aug 2017, 07:10
Posts: 43
pandora charms
coach factory outlet online
christian louboutin shoes
ralph lauren uk
cheap jordan shoes
red bottom
kd shoes
canada goose outlet
pandora uk
michael kors handbags outlet
beats wireless headphones
moncler outlet online
nike sneakers
fitflop
adidas nmd r1
cubs jerseys
sac longchamp
burberry outlet online
ecco outlet
gucci outlet online
ray ban sunglasses outlet
canada goose jackets uk
canada goose coats
canada goose parka
yeezy boost 350
coach factory outlet online
cheap ugg boots
pandora charms outlet
rockets jerseys
nfl jerseys cheap
ghd hair
oakley sunglasses outlet
air jordan retro
pandora jewelry
michael kors outlet clearance
adidas superstars
michael kors bags
nike store
chaussures louboutin
air max
ralph lauren outlet online
jimmy choo shoes
ugg outlet online
ralph lauren
adidas yeezy boost 350
ralph lauren outlet online
fitflop sandals
polo ralph lauren pas cher
nike store
nike outlet store
kate spade handbags
ralph lauren
coach factory outlet online
moncler jackets
pandora charms sale clearance
pandora
beats headphones
polo ralph lauren
vans outlet
birkin handbags
ralph lauren
vans store
polo ralph lauren outlet
nmd adidas
toms
michael kors outlet online
bottes ugg
mlb jerseys
gucci
christian louboutin shoes
coach factory outlet
adidas nmd runner
adidas yeezy boost
warriors jerseys
ray bans
fitflop shoes
coach factory outlet online
nike outlet
adidas yeezy shoes
louboutin shoes
cardinals jerseys
sac louis vuitton pas cher
nike sneakers
ugg outlet
michael kors outlet
birkenstock uk
michael kors
eahawks jerseys
white sox jerseys
cheap jordan shoes
adidas outlet online
christian louboutin
adidas outlet store
louis vuitton bags
valentino outlet
ray ban glasses
christian louboutin sale
gucci handbags outlet
longchamp sale
dansko outlet
michael kors
adidas nmd r1
nike outlet online
ugg outlet online
pandora charms outlet
giuseppe shoes
coach outlet store online
dolce and gabbana outlet online
fitflops sale clearance
kate spade outlet
adidas outlet online
retro 11
michael kors outlet store
yeezy boost 350
uggs
michael kors outlet online
pandora charms
fitflops
adidas nmd runner
coach outlet online
texans jerseys
coach outlet online
michael kors outlet store
kate spade handbags
yeezy boost
polo ralph lauren outlet online
adidas nmd runner
ugg boots
michael kors outlet canada
louis vuitton purses
adidas sneakers
michael kors uk
levis outlet
red sox jerseys
harden vol 1
yeezy shoes
canada goose jackets
coach factory outlet online
michael kors outlet clearance
ugg outlet online
nike huarache shoes
coach factory outlet online
ralph lauren uk
coach outlet online
pandora outlet
yeezy boost
coach factory outlet online
pandora bijoux
pandora charms
fitflops sale clearance
longchamp handbags
tiffany and co jewelry
canada goose coats
hermes bags
birkenstock outlet
kate spade outlet
true religion jeans
louis vuitton outlet online
yeezy shoes
discount oakley sunglasses
canada goose jackets
cheap jordan shoes
ray ban sunglasses sale
adidas superstar trainers
canada goose jackets
uggs outlet
jordans
dansko
fred perry polo shirts
gucci bags
cheap nfl jerseys wholesale
coach outlet online
moncler uk
nike outlet
fitflops sale
uggs outlet
salomon outlet
michael kors outlet online
coach factory outlet
birkenstock shoes
rolex replica watches for sale
ray ban sunglasses discount
rangers jerseys
toms outlet
cheap ray ban sunglasses
yeezy shoes
giuseppe zanotti sale
adidas ultra boost
ugg sale
discount oakley sunglasses
ralph lauren outlet online
canada goose
valentino outlet
fitflops sandals
adidas yeezy boost
hermes bag
cheap jerseys
coach factory outlet online
coach outlet canada
harden shoes
louboutin outlet
salomon boots 
uggs outlet
dodgers jerseys
kate spade outlet online
ugg
moncler outlet online
yeezy boost 350
toms
coach factory outlet online
pandora jewelry
cheap jordan shoes
coach outlet store
coach outlet online
louis vuitton factory outlet
michael kors outlet canada
cheap air jordans
coach outlet online
pandora charms sale clearance
fitflops sale clearance
coach factory outlet online
pandora charms sale
fitflops sale
coach factory outlet online
nike cortez classic
ray ban sunglasses discount
coach outlet
sac louis vuitton
giants jerseys
air max
true religion jeans outlet
ray ban sunglasses outlet
toms
birkenstock outlet
chi flat iron
oakley sunglasses outlet
kate spade outlet online
christian louboutin shoes
michael kors
ray bans
pandora charms sale clearance
red bottom heels
coach outlet online
coach outlet online
yankees jerseys
gucci outlet online
swarovski crystals
cowboys jerseys
cheap ugg boots
coach purses
ralph lauren sale
michael kors
air max
fitflop sandals
nike free 4.0 flyknit
columbia outlet store
coach outlet store
pandora charms outlet
mulberry
nike air max 2018
ralph lauren outlet
coach outlet online
longchamp bags
ed hardy outlet
adidas superstar
beats by dre
uggs outlet
true religion jeans outlet
yeezy boost
polo ralph lauren outlet
tods outlet
kate spade outlet
49ers jerseys
mulberry handbags
louis vuitton factory outlet
coach outlet store online clearance
valentino
clarks shoes for women
gucci handbags outlet
nike sneakers
michael kors handbags outlet
adidas outlet
mbt
ralph lauren outlet
pandora jewelry store
coach outlet online
nike flyknit
michael kors outlet online
ghd straighteners sale
ugg boots
canada goose jackets
coach factory outlet online
clarks shoes outlet
oakley sunglasses outlet
pandora jewelry outlet
coach outlet online
jordan uk
toms outlet
pandora uk
ugg on sale
christian louboutin pas cher
patriots jerseys
uggs outlet
hermes outlet
mlb jerseys whgolesale
fitflops clearance
birkenstocks
cavaliers jerseys
birkenstock outlet store
moncler coats
uggs outlet
michael kors outlet online
adidas nmd r1
coach factory outlet online
moncler pas cher
cat boots
gucci bags
pandora soldes
mbt
coach outlet online
michael kors outlet store
pandora charms sale clearance
tiffany jewelry
ray ban sunglasses cheap
ralph lauren outlet
adidas superstars
columbia outlet
ralph lauren sale
michael kors outlet store
pandora charms sale clearance
coach outlet online
pandora charms sale
birkenstocks
tory burch shoes
coach outlet online
christian louboutin shoes
michael kors outlet online
louboutin shoes
nfl jerseys
ralph lauren sale clearance uk
broncos jerseys
longchamps
mlb jerseys
coach factory outlet online
polo ralph lauren outlet online
purs jerseys
fred perry shirts
air max pas cher
pandora charms sale clearance
adidas outlet store
mulberry outlet uk
ugg boots outlet
thunder jerseys
air jordan shoes
louis vuitton outlet store
yeezy shoes
nike free run flyknit
canada goose sale
nike outlet store online
coach factory outlet
ralph lauren sale clearance uk
gucci borse
cheap jordans for sale
polo ralph lauren outlet online
birkenstock
michael kors
fit flops
phillies jerseys
longchamp bags
cheap oakley sunglasses
uggs outlet
kd 8 shoes
kate spade bags
adidas superstar shoes
birkenstock shoes
christian louboutin sale
polo ralph lauren outlet online
kate spade uk
canada goose jackets
birkenstock
nfl jerseys wholesale
bulls jerseys
oakley sunglasses outlet
cheap ray ban sunglasses
rolex replica watches
coach factory outlet
mbt
michael kors outlet store
cheap oakley sunglasses
coach outlet store online
celtics jerseys
nike outlet store
coach outlet online
ugg canada
jordan shoes
cheap ray ban sunglasses
tiffany and co outlet
discount oakley sunglasses
tigers jerseys
moncler jackets
cheap nike shoes
air max shoes
burberry outlet
louis vuitton outlet store
tiffany jewelry outlet
mlb jerseys
coach outlet online
louis vuitton outlet online
hermes bags
moncler uk
packers jerseys
fitflops sale clearance
pandora jewelry outlet
ralph lauren sale
louboutin outlet
coach outlet store online
uggs outlet
mulberry uk
coach outlet online
longchamp handbags
tory burch outlet online
rolex watches
rolex replica watches for sale
kate spade outlet store
ugg boots
cheap uggs
kate spade outlet online
ed hardy store
ray ban glasses
longchamp
coach factory outlet
coach handbags outlet
cheap uggs
ugg boots
heat jerseys
cheap ugg sale
pandora charms outlet
ugg boots
gucci
wireless beats headphones
lakers jerseys
adidas store
tods shoes
under armour outlet
nike free run
coach outlet store
20170817yueqin


Top
 Profile  
 
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 5 posts ] 

All times are UTC - 5 hours


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 13 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group