The Round Table (Rational Pagans Forum)

Science & The Supernatural: A Discussion of the World Around us - Based on Science with an Interest in the Supernatural ...
It is currently 08 Apr 2020, 05:53

All times are UTC - 5 hours

Forum rules

Please note: Discussion here should be relatively civil. Attack the post, not the poster. Thanks!

Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 5 posts ] 
Author Message
PostPosted: 06 Apr 2010, 21:27 
Grand Poobah
User avatar

Joined: 18 Sep 2007, 11:26
Posts: 5793
Location: Buffalo, NY ... al_notions

Freedom of Inquiry and Other Medieval Notions

Austin Dacey
April 2, 2010
Freedom of Inquiry and Other Medieval Notions

A meeting of doctors at the University of Paris

It was March, and the air at the University of Paris was restive. Spring was bringing a confrontation between the forces of tradition and the ideals of freedom that would have far-reaching consequences for life in the modern West ever after. But this was not the overcrowded suburban branch campus of Nanterre where on March 22, 1968, student protesters took over administration buildings, touching off waves of unrest that crested in the upheavals of May ’68. The year was 1277, and the revolutionaries were not the undergraduates but the faculty. The spokesman for the established order was not the Office of the Dean but the Bishop of Paris, Stephen Tempier.

In March 1277, Bishop Tempier promulgated a now-famous condemnation of 219 errors in theology and natural philosophy that he believed were being entertained and discussed by scholars of the university's faculty of arts. Among this syllabus of errors appeared the following propositions:

That there is no more excellent state than to study philosophy.

That the only wise men in the world are the philosophers.

That one should not hold anything unless it is self-evident or can be manifested by self-evident principles.

That man should not be content with authority to have certitude about any question.

That there is no rationally disputable question that the philosopher ought not to dispute and determine, because reasons are derived from things. It belongs to philosophy under one or another of its parts to consider all things.

That our intellect by its own natural power can attain to a knowledge of the first cause.

That we can know God by His essence in this mortal life.

The Condemnation of 1277 was intended to control discussion of theological matters being carried out by members of the faculty. The Bishop’s chief concern seems to have been that too many were choosing Aristotle over God. Above all, the Condemnation asserted God’s power to bring about anything he chooses, short of a logical contradiction. This absolute power appeared to be subverted by those who, under the sway of the philosopher, sought to explain the world as a system of natural causes and principles.i Under Tempier’s decree, they would now do so on pain of excommunication.

The point of revisiting these events is not to raise three cheers for the forbidden beliefs (although I must confess that as a philosopher, I find the first two extremely self-evident). The point is to uncover some unexpected answers to why the scientific revolution happened in Western Europe and not in Arabic-Islamic societies, where its preconditions had existed for centuries.
The Medieval Invention of Society

In the popular imagination—particularly among friends of Reason and Enlightenment—the story of the rise of science is the story of the monolith of Church power being shattered by individual heroes like Bruno and Galileo. In this narrative, the scientists are champions of personal freedom as much as the soixant huitards of Nanterre. Astronomy under Islam, meanwhile, remains medieval because Islam’s power remains totalitarian. While this telling of the story contains much truth that is by now familiar, it also obscures some truth that is counterintuitive and far less appreciated.

The thirteenth-century intellectual struggle at the University of Paris illuminates how Christianity had already helped to prepare the way (in many ways inadvertently) for free, naturalistic inquiry. This had less to do with Christian doctrine as such than with certain innovations in Church law developed in the preceding two centuries.

When we hear the story of 1277 today, we must not take for granted its most important fact: there was something to which the condemnation was addressed. The university was not an extension of Church hierarchy but rather an independent institution with its own identity, purpose, and structure.ii The punishments that the Bishop could bring to bear as disincentives to discourage heresy were not civil but religious. He could threaten errant scholastics with removing their rights to membership in the Body of Christ; he could not determine by ecclesiastical fiat the curriculum of the university or the membership of its faculty. But what is for us unremarkable was once unthinkable.

Paradoxically, the relative independence of the University of Paris, and countless institutions like it, was a result of an earlier assertion of Church authority now known as the papal revolution. Beginning in the middle of the eleventh century, the hierarchy struggled to free itself from interference by secular officials, from the local to the imperial level, who claimed jurisdiction over religious affairs. The key battle was over secular rulers’ claim to responsibility for the appointment or investiture of clergy like bishops and abbots, the so-called “investiture controversy.” It began in 1076 with Pope Gregory VII excommunicating a defiant Emperor Henry IV, who shot back that the pope had become a “false monk.” It ended with the Concordat of Worms of 1122, which liberated the Church from imperial control.
Masters of the Universitas

To explicate and legitimize the emerging political settlements, Christian monks wove together church law and European common law with the resources of the Roman legal tradition—by way of recently discovered manuscripts—to invent the novel system of canon law. In this system, the church would function as a distinct and legally autonomous collective entity with the right to own property, to assemble, to enact and judge its own statutes, and to engage in representative governance, both internal to itself and externally in the broader civil and political order—in a word, it would become a corporation. As Harold J. Berman contends in Law and Revolution, the papal revolution opened the door for the creation of similar entities in the secular world, making possible a new model of society as an aggregate of multiple collective agents, each with its own legal jurisdiction.iii

By at least 1215, the scholars at the University of Paris had established themselves as one such corporate body. Indeed, university comes from the Latin term for corporation, universitas. It was in virtue of the university’s independent institutional powers that fifty years later the faculty of arts could vote to enact a statute that made required reading of the natural works of Aristotle, the very books the good Bishop wished he could close but couldn’t.

The popular narrative is correct that the evolution of science depended on the emancipation of thought from Christian power. Yet this very emancipation depended on a structural transformation of European life set in motion by Christian power itself, as has been argued convincingly by the historian of science Toby E. Huff.iv And it is not individual freedom but corporate freedom that deserves the role of chief protagonist. As I will explore in my next column, the comparative failure of science under Islam is not explained by a lack of individualism but rather an excess of it, a failure to develop institutions that could serve as the home of independent inquiry.

iEdward Grant, “Science and Theology in the Middle Ages,” in David C. Lindberg and Ronald L. Numbers, eds., God and Nature: Historical Essays on the Encounter between Christianity and Science (Los Angeles: University of California Press, 1986), 55.

iiToby E. Huff, The Rise of Early Modern Science: Islam, China, and the West (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993), 194.

iiiHarold J. Berman, Law and Revolution: The Formation of the Western Legal Tradition (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1983).

Austin Dacey, Ph.D., is former director of Science and the Public, a program of the Center for Inquiry and State University of New York at Buffalo, and author of several articles and books, including The Secular Conscience. He holds a doctorate in applied ethics and social philosophy and has taught most recently at Polytechnic Institute of New York University.

Chloride and Sodium: Two terribly dangerous substances that taste great together!

PostPosted: 07 Apr 2010, 10:27 
'Lustrous Potentate
User avatar

Joined: 24 Mar 2010, 11:06
Posts: 411
Very interesting article!

I have no doubt that the use of the corporation concept in civil society was an unintended consequence from the church's perspective.

PostPosted: 11 Apr 2010, 15:41 
Guardian of the East

Joined: 22 Dec 2008, 02:47
Posts: 589
I think that saying that giving credit to Xianity is rather misleading, and the sort of thing that Xian readers will want to believe. Though its author complains about the autocratic-Church stereotype, what was going on here clearly fits it. But it could well be that the Church had started something that came back to bite them.

I do agree about power struggles, however. The Western Church had lots of them with leaders in its territory, and it succeeded in winning some independence. Theologians penned a lot of arguments for limiting the power of kings, and some of them even argued that sovereignty resides in the people and not some monarch. It was a way of promoting the Pope over the kings, but some centuries later, these writings became useful as defenses of democracy.

PostPosted: 09 Sep 2014, 03:10 

Joined: 09 Sep 2014, 01:46
Posts: 1
Good article.Your article is very informative and interesting.Keep it up and share more articles.

PostPosted: 09 Dec 2016, 02:08 

Joined: 09 Dec 2016, 00:53
Posts: 80
<P>basket coach black friday of tory burch handbags fish. toms shoes But toms shoes outlet they uggs outlet did oakley sunglasses not nike air yeezy go burberry our raiders nfl jersey separate burberry sale ways, bottega veneta but new balance agreed canada gooses outlet to mizuno running work polo ralph lauren together cheap oakley to nike find ralph lauren online shop the beats audio sea, hollister co They 49ers nfl jersey only pandora cook michael kors a ray ban outlet online fish the north face each texans nfl jersey time salomon they air max travel cheap michael kors through hogan outlet the air max 90 distant, omega watches came ferragamo shoes to bears nfl jersey the michael kors outlet beach, michael kors bags then eagles nfl jersey the vans shoes two michael kors canada began barbour jackets a toms outlet day longchamp outlet of coach bags fishing, cheap nike shoes a rolex replica few ray ban black friday years polo ralph after, nike air max 2014 they built oakley sunglasses a true religion jeans men house, ray ban sunglasses outlet with hilfiger online shop their swarovski canada respective nike families, children ray bans have their nike air huarache own nike outlet store fishing longchamp boats nike roche run built, orlando magic jersey and puma sneakers lived nike air max a prada sunglasses happy dsquared2 jeans and michael kors peaceful timberland boots life.A jimmy choo shoes person oakley sunglasses outlet only ray ban the longchamp handbags immediate bengals nfl jersey interests hollister will eventually tommy hilfiger get michael kors outlet online the joy free run was kings jersey short-lived; new balance a san antonio spurs jersey goal ralph lauren will ralph lauren black friday be uggs on sale high, lacoste outlet online but ray ban wayfarer we toms shoes must atlanta hawks jersey face michael kors the ralph lauren outlet online reality golden state warriors jerseys of abercrombie fitch life, ugg australia only watches canada the polo ralph lauren outlet online ideal ray ban sunglasses outlet and cheap nhl jerseys reality tommy hilfiger combine hugo boss clothes it raptors jersey be louboutin outlet possible nike free to kevin durant jersey become five finger shoes a uggs successful oakley person.We burberry sale often air max 2015 times of nike air max difficulties, basketball shoes even tory burch outlet to hollisterco the ray ban outlet critical red bottom shoes moment, long champ suddenly coach outlet sale someone air jordan shoes else's true religion help, red bottoms we jaguars nfl jersey like pandora schmuck straw boston celtics caught longchamp black friday in nike roshe the cheap nhl jerseys storm, burberry like michael kors outlet online clinging designer handbags to coach store online hold rams nfl jersey nothing the north face outlet to burberry handbags consider, coach factory outlet online despite abercrombie and fitch kids everything armani shoes outlet , givenchy handbags and oakley sunglasses cheap desperately, ugg grasp nike outlet it azcardinals nfl jersey firmly, timberland shoes on woolrich mens jackets hand, air max one while ralph lauren outlet online ignoring jordan jerseys the juicy couture outlet thought, hermes birkin bag like lunette oakley accidentally bcbg max azria than ralph lauren not nike huaraches swim levi's jeans out north face of hollister kids the cheap jerseys water, toms shoes outlet desperately converse struggling burberry handbags outlet in versace clothes the jordan water, wizards jersey into fossil uhren the celine bags water falcons nfl jersey to longchamp save nike free run him asics if omega watches someone, michael kors handbags he ray ban sonnenbrillen will cheap michael kors firmly cowboys nfl jersey grasp oakley sunglasses outlet this jimmy choo outlet person, burberry sale and michael kors handbags this discount shoes result tommy hilfiger is fake rolex that michael kors this nike Air Max Plaza is ralph lauren polo to nike outlet save swarovski crystal people knicks jersey who vans grasped burberry outlet online him ugg firmly, ravens nfl jersey but polo ralph lauren do chiefs nfl jersey not north face outlet put philadelphia 76ers jerseys hands ugg boots clearance and canada gooses feet michael kors handbags open, nba jersey lose steelers nfl jersey the air force ability broncos nfl jersey to ugg swim, michael kors purses so adidas outlet that mcm handbags two converse people burberry outlet store are longchamp outlet not nba jerseys out longchamp water.Of calvin klein underwear course, adidas online we kate spade outlet online do not oakley sunglasses outlet mean air max 90 to jordans save, north face backpacks not ralph lauren outlet online to pandora uk say ed hardy pretended toms shoes not grizzlies jersey to cheap jerseys see, ray ban we jazz jersey need oakley vault the michael kors handbags wisdom insanity workout of coach outlet canada the new balance shoes mind, horloges to giuseppe shoes make kate spade outlet online the bcbg max right jerseys from china judgments, ray ban no burberry handbags outlet matter cheap michael kors how swarovski online difficult uggs black friday things, pacers jersey I marc jacobs believe coach purses factory that burberry handbags the ray ban outlet principle buccaneers nfl jersey of bills nfl jersey the adidas method air max is cheap jerseys better replica rolex than oakley canada more beats by dr dre difficult, coach handbags the ralph lauren factory store use timberland outlet of northface intelligence, dwyane wade jersey hyperactivity nike brains, north face rather chargers nfl jersey than converse shoes blindly redskins nfl jersey thirst moncler jackets to cheap mlb jerseys see whether eyeglasses stores or new orleans pelicans not michael kors bags direct asics gel used mbt mens shoes to nike free run 5.0 use, colts nfl jersey and ralph lauren online then browns nfl jersey there softball bats is nike mercurial a bucks jersey problem, mcm handbags outlet we ralph lauren need to chi flat iron look roshe run at jets nfl jersey whether aktienkurse adidas remembered titans nfl jersey what ferragamo circumstances, thomas sabo but oakley sunglasses this giants nfl jersey time handbags outlet has cheap oakley sunglasses been hilfiger outlet too brooklyn nets jersey late.Just marc jacobs before charlotte hornets jerseys the ray bans two hungry converse sneakers people prada shoes in mcm handbags the swarovski jewelry story indoor soccer shoes told, thomas sabo only cheap clothes to hermes meet oakley black friday their katespade own ralph lauren for michael kors handbags a cheap true religion short salvatore ferragamo while, replica rolex without celine black friday considering new balance outlet the swarovski other, adidas he jordans was air jordans thirty ray ban outlet tube moncler jackets outlet XXI nike she nike air max 2014 had omega to coach store eat, or nike shoes outlet that coach factory outlet he dolphins nfl jersey can barbour outlet online have kate spade bags fishing michael kors taschen tool hollister on supra shoes the nba jersey line, michael kors day air jordan retro to barbour jackets day, valentino whether prada handbags it hilfiger outlet be nfl jerseys after instyler it, adidas outlet we chaussure timberland feel cheap oakley sunglasses sad soccer shoes for occhiali ray ban them, roshe while trail blazers jersey in coach handbags fact michael kors black friday in uggs which nike canada we knockoff handbags live, straightener we vans sometimes hermes bags are hogan the polo ralph lauren outlet same, oakley vault there ray-ban sunglasses is oakley no cheap true religion long-term denver nuggets jersey goal, not uggs lofty prada ideals, ray ban and ugg boots just ray ban sunglasses goof oakley today cheap barbour jackets gone, kobe bryant jerseys tomorrow guess outlet online is dallas mavericks jerseys another uggs day, adidas life air max is packers nfl jersey short, rolex watches had coach outlet finished nike today, burberry although christian louboutin shoes it chi hair will cheap glasses come cavaliers jerseys tomorrow, pandora jewelry but clippers jersey today north face jackets we giuseppe zanotti sneakers have cartier montres to ralph lauren outlet come toms shoes back hollister who cheap mlb jerseys can reebok save saints nfl jersey it.Years north face of mont blanc age air max a tory burch handbags man, michael kors time coach handbags outlet waits pandora charms for tommy hilfiger no lunette ray ban one, p90x although abercrombie kids we mcm bags can baseball bats not nike air max change hollister the burberry sale length fendi bags of abercrombie life, ralph lauren uk but swarovski jewelry can barbour jackets try timberwolves jersey to handbags outlet change tn pas cher the uggs outlet width true religion jeans women of michael kors outlet life Yeah! occhiali oakley Full roshe runs day, michael kors black friday a coach outlet online day iphone 5 cases wasted huarache effort ugg is veneta the burberry outlet day adidas canada ill ugg boots spent coach black friday a dre beats day, vikings nfl jersey the michael kors purses pain seahawks nfl jersey is juicy couture day, ralph lauren polos happy louboutin uk day, lions nfl jersey overcast uggs on sale day, ipad mini cases bright tory burch shoes day, rockets jersey why panthers nfl jersey can nike roshe not michael kors we nike air max have babyliss pro lived mcm bags up coach factory online to it's nike shoes wonderful!Own new balance canada way, north face no patriots nfl jersey one beats by dr dre for louboutin us prada outlet to puma online go, cheap jordans their phoenix suns pain, pandora and true religion outlet no wedding dresses one cheap oakley sunglasses for louboutin outlet us plein outlet points, cheap ray ban </P>michael kors bags

Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Post new topic Reply to topic  [ 5 posts ] 

All times are UTC - 5 hours

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 129 guests

You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group